Reasons to urge Secretary Miguel Cardona, U.S. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, House Education Committee Chair Rep. Bobby Scott, Majority Leader Sen. Chuck Schumer, United States Senate Health, Labor and Education Committee , Senate HELP Committee Chair Patty Murray, U.S. D.O.E. Secretary Miguel Cardona to urge states, especially Florida, to participate and request a waiver, relieving students and schools from the mental stress of unfair and inequitable 2021 spring testing during the COVID-19 pandemic:
I urge you to instruct states, especially Florida, to participate and request a waiver, relieving students and schools from the mental stress of unfair and inequitable 2021 spring testing during the COVID-19 pandemic. Because of the ongoing presence of COVID-19 in communities across Florida, the delayed effort to vaccinate teachers and staff and the lack of resources released to Florida schools for strict adherence to CDC safety guidelines, we ask the Federal Government to generously accept waivers for the annual testing requirement and the mandate for “95 % tested” required in ESSA.
- Because of the ongoing presence of COVID-19 in communities across Florida, the delayed effort to vaccinate teachers and staff and the lack of resources released to Florida schools for strict adherence to CDC safety guidelines, we urge the Federal Government to generously accept waivers for the annual testing requirement and the mandate for “95 % tested” required in ESSA.
- As other states apply for Federal 2021 testing waivers, parents living in red states actively throwing out local mask mandates remain opposed to returning their students for face-to-face testing, especially after being assured by districts and the state of Florida that remote or virtual learning was “their choice” and that “parents know best.”
- It is inequitable and unrealistic to expect parents, who the state encouraged to exercise their “choice,” to keep their students out of face-to-face instruction over health risks to return these same students to a face-to-face school building to take the FSA.
- FSA results gathered in spring 2021, during COVID-19, will not provide an accurate picture of student progress, teacher effectiveness and school performance and as such should not be used to retain students, rank teachers or grade schools.
- Florida Districts have already been required to collect “robust progress monitoring” data, spending upwards of $20 million in CARES funding to create this infrastructure for collecting, aggregating, and analyzing student data.
- During the 2021 Florida Legislature’s Pandemic Committee meeting it was expressed that the “robust progress monitoring” data collected on Florida K-12 students using embedded programs such as a-Ready are already providing teachers and districts plenty of information about student progress. This data has been shared regularly with the state FL DOE, documenting progress, and holding districts accountable – making the argument to administer spring FSA moot.
- Florida Standard Assessments (FSA) test prep will rob as much as two months of valuable teaching time needed to help students mitigate the negative impacts brought on by COVID-19.
- How can the spring 2021 FSA be valid or reliable given that methods and content for teaching school this year are in no way “standardized?” During the 2020-21 school year Florida students used a variety of alternative learning environments such as synchronous distance learning, virtual school, and homeschooling and returning to optional face to face in January 2021.
